THE PROJECT
About | Summary | Hall |
L'Affaire Eagleson
| Committee | Rules | Initial Thoughts
| New-Found Respect For the Chore?
  ELECTIONS
 
DIFFERENCES OF OPINIONS
World Wide Hall of Fame vs.
Toronto Hall of Fame
FEEDBACK
Submit Comments
PRINT VERSION
Download (PDF)
 

ELECTIONS: 1949

We had a full ballot for the first time, with all 20 members casting votes.

We took the top three vote getters for the Honoured Players category, and held firm on the 75% rule for the other categories. We had a tie for third, so we elected four members. Some of our committee wondered quite loudly if we were inducting too many people too early. Other committee members voiced concerns that we were not electing enough members.

"Coming into the last three ballots, I had Fred Waghorne pencilled in as a referee. He had 14 votes. He finished with 14 votes. This was a strange election. After 10 ballots, Ebbie Goodfellow was leading Eddie Shore," said Chair Morey Holzman.
Joe Pellietier was ecstatic with the results.

"I couldn't be more pleased with the results of this election, as Boucher, Goodfellow and Smith are all personal favorites. Shore was a no brainer," Pelletier said.

Our other Joe, Joseph Nieforth, was less than thrilled that Harry "Hap" Holmes was dropped from the ballot due to lack of support.

"I am truly surprised that Harry Holmes was dropped from the ballot. He only backstopped four Stanley Cup winners and appeared in the undecided 1919 series," Nieforth said.

Tommy Gorman and Fred Waghorne finished with fourteen votes, instead of the require fifteen. Under a weighted system, they probably would have been elected. Instead, they would have to wait at least one more year.

The class of 1949:

HONOURED MEMBERS:

FRANK BOUCHER (C)
EBBIE GOODFELLOW (LW-D)
  EDDIE SHORE (D)
REGINALD "HOOLEY" SMITH (C)

Here is how the final voting went:

OLDTIMERS
Phillips, Tommy 12
Bowie, Russel 11
Dunderdale, Tommy10
Grant, Mike 10
Bain, Dan 9
Hall, Joe 7
McGee, Frank 7
Pitre, Didier 7
Stuart, Hod 4
Laviolette, Jack 3
Lehman, Hugh 3
Pulford, Harvey 3
Smith, Tommy 3
Darragh, Jack 2
Griffis, Si 2
Hern, Riley 2
Prodgers, Goldie 1
Russell, Ernie 1

HONOURED PLAYERS
Shore, Eddie 17
Goodfellow, Ebbie 14
Boucher, Frank 13
Smith, Hooley 13
Johnson, Moose 10
Jackson, Busher 9
Cameron, Harry 6
Johnson, Ching 6
Cook, Bun 4
Aurie, Larry 2
Bailey, Ace 1
Barry, Marty 1

MANAGERS/EXECS/REFS
Waghorne, Fred 14
Creighton, James 13
Muldoon, Pete 11
Hart, Cecil 5

BUILDERS
Gorman, Tommy 14
Adams, Jack 12
Irvin, Dick 12
Taylor, Cyclone 10
Stanley, Lord Frederic 9
Hartley, 4
Patton 4
Ross, Phil 4