THE PROJECT
About | Summary | Hall |
L'Affaire Eagleson
| Committee | Rules | Initial Thoughts
| New-Found Respect For the Chore?
  ELECTIONS
 
DIFFERENCES OF OPINIONS
World Wide Hall of Fame vs.
Toronto Hall of Fame
FEEDBACK
Submit Comments
PRINT VERSION
Download (PDF)
 

ELECTIONS: 1960

Chair Morey Holzman introduced what would amount to be the final rule change in the election proceedings. Due to clogging on the lists, largely due to committee members voting for their favorite player even though the rest of the committee is not supporting the nominee, Holzman's new rule stated that a candidate must be on at least four ballots to stay on the list.

This fractured the ballot as little, as this election became known as the Near Miss Election.

Sid Abel squeaked in with 15 votes, but Elmer Lach, Tommy Smith, Hap Day, James Creighton and Builder Candidate Foster Hewitt fell one vote shy.

HONOURED MEMBERS:

SID ABEL (C)
   

Here is how the final voting went:

OLDTIMERS
Smith, T 14
Worters, Roy "Shrimp" 13
Bain 9
Chabot, Lorne 9
Dunderdale 9
Hall, Joe 6
Grant, Mike 5
McGee, Frank 5
Holmes 4
Stuart, H 4
Griffis 3
Lehman 3
Pulford, Harvey 3
Bailey, Ace 2
Campbell, L 2
Laviolette 2
Prodgers 2
Russell, E 2
Simpson 2 1
Hern, Riley 1

HONOURED PLAYERS
Abel, Sid 15
Lach, Elmer 14
Howe, Syd 13
Schmidt, Milt 13
Cowley, Bill 9
Brimsek, Frankie 7
Bauer, Bobby 4
Cook, Bun 4
Stewart, Jack 4
Weiland, Cooney* 3
Barry, Marty 2
Schriner, Sweeney 2
Aurie, Larry 1
Drillon, Gordie 1
Dumart, Woody 1
Gagnon 1
Hextall, Bryan 1
Meeker, Howie 1
Patrick, Lynn 1
Reardon, Kenny 1
Stewart, Gaye 1

COACHES/MANAGERS/
EXECUTIVES/REFEREES

Creighton 14
Day, Clarence "Hap" 14
Livingstone, Ed 12
Muldoon 10
Kennedy, George 8
Stanley, F 7
Northey, William 6
Calder, F 4
Hartley 4
Hart 3
Gibson, Jack 1
Patton 1

BUILDERS
Hewitt, Foster 14
Blake, Toe 10
Shore, Eddie 4
Taylor 4